Custom Commander Decks!

At Thursday Night Magic, we’ve spent 20+ years turning kitchen tables into epic battlefields and strangers into friends.

With over 50,000 positive eBay reviews, our specialty is hand-tuned, ready-to-play Commander decks crafted by players who live the grind. Every card is tournament-legal, authentic, and near-mint condition. Every deck is optimized for flow, synergy and fun—whether you’re grabbing your first deck or hunting your next powerhouse. Our mission never changes: make game night legendary.

Own the deck to own the table. Start your collection today!

Shop All Decks >Shop all Colors >

Shop by Color

Not sure what color identity fits your game?

Move the sliders, get your colors.

In under a minute, we’ll recommend the best Commander color identity (plus close matches) and link you to decks that fit.

Color ID Quiz >

Premium Decks

Top-tier builds. No compromises.

View all
1 15

Rare Finds

Rare today, gone tomorrow.

View all
1 15

Value Commanders

Play hard, spend light.

View all
1 15

About Us

Thursday Night Magic has been crafting decks for over two decades for 23 years, helping players summon better decks and better game nights.

We specialize in handcrafted, ready-to-play Commander decks built by real players who love the game. Every list is tuned for synergy, flow, and fun—so whether you're just starting out or optimizing your fifth build, there's something here for you.

We’ve seen metas change, legends rise, and power creep... creep. Through it all, our goal has stayed the same:

Own the Deck to Own the Table.

About Us

Let customers speak for us

from 2273 reviews
Flawless transaction

Everything came perfectly. No issues at all.

jerry53
Thursday Night Magic
Impressed with the delivery speed

Really impressed with how quickly and cleanly the package arrived.

sadams
Thursday Night Magic
Better than described

Arrived faster than expected and everything was better than described.

tstevens
Thursday Night Magic
They genuinely care

You can tell they care.

davidlong
Thursday Night Magic
Great pricing and communication

Great pricing, great communication, great seller.

prichards
Thursday Night Magic
Fast and reliable

Exactly as described, never had an issue.

zsmith
Thursday Night Magic
Everything about the transaction was smooth

Everything about the transaction was smooth. Great company to deal with.

jcampos
Thursday Night Magic
People behind this store are great

Really great people behind this shop.

denisehall
Thursday Night Magic
Fast, accurate, and easy

Always fast, always right. Never disappointed.

carlosfoster
Thursday Night Magic
Repeat customer, always impressed

Repeat customer and I’m always impressed with the consistency and quality.

nhall
Thursday Night Magic
Had an issue with shipping and they responded immediately

Had an issue with shipping and they responded immediately. Sent a replacement at no cost. Fantastic service.

ronald40
Thursday Night Magic
Great packaging and protection

They really do an amazing job packaging and protecting the product.

justin21
Thursday Night Magic
Zero hassle order

I reached out with a question and got a helpful response in minutes.

jamiejordan
Thursday Night Magic
Cards arrived on time and looked perfect

Cards arrived on time and looked perfect. Can't say enough good things about this seller.

lisa56
Thursday Night Magic
Probably the best commander deck seller I've found

Probably the best commander deck seller I've found. Every time I order, it ships quickly and arrives as described. Thank you!

ewilcox
Thursday Night Magic